My 4-star review represents disappointment with the noise and mayhem at this normally elegant restaurant, plus a degree of unhappiness with the limited menu. FAIL !!! Who wears shorts to a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay? At this price point, the ambiance, service and food should be much better. I don't have a strong opinion other than recommending some white linen pants and no socks. king of correct score . Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews. More elaborate dishes were less successful. I mean, it is BIZARRE. We're thinking of just coming in for a drunk tonight. More about Highlawn Pavilion . Many people come to order good hot fudge sundae, fudge and chocolate mousse. @conandrob240, I think he is saying that he was wearing dress shorts with a button down business shirt. In December 1985, Harry and Wade Knowles traveled throughout northern Italy seeking design elements and color schemes to inform The Highlawns dcor. Loved the bar and live music. The bar is different than the dining room.). Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates. An outstanding job. After 35 year, Highlawn Pavilion changes owners with a reopening on the horizon, The Highlawn in West Orange hires key personal ahead of relaunch, ROI Influencers: Food & Beverage 2021 (A to F). Land for Essex County Eagle Rock Reservation was purchased by the. Kind of pricey, but you're paying for the setting and view of NYC. Sun 11:00 am3:00 pm HOURS OF OPERATIONTuesday - Friday: 11:30AM - 3PM (Lunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner)Saturday 5PM- 10PM (Dinner & Bar)Sunday: 11:00AM -3PM (Brunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner). Dude, dressing up means basically not wearing jeans or shorts, at this point in history. Second waiter took our order. Loved everything & cant wait to return to enjoy the outside patio! This building is beautiful Mediterranean style architecture. I'm working on him making an exception for my birthday because I want to go to Le Bernadin, but so far no success! Ladies were dressed in casual sundresses, dressy short outfits to cocktail type dresses. Highlawn Pavilion, West Orange: See 405 unbiased reviews of Highlawn Pavilion, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 101 restaurants in West Orange. 281 photos. I don't have a strong opinion other than recommending some white linen pants and no socks. Great food, SUPERB service (thank you PAT! Shorts are not appropriate for every venue, dressing appropriately for the occasion isn't so 80's but the sense of entitlement in your post is so very 2014. We had such a lovely evening and will be dining here again soon! Want to book a hotel in New Jersey? That said, if I did, and managed to be seated and have an order taken while wearing said shorts, and only THEN was asked to leave, the clueless twit managing the place wouldn't know what hit him. Who wears shorts to a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay? Ok, I'm calling Shenanigans on Rayo and Ilovepink - in this thread they are acting like they don't know each other but in a thread last year Rayo said he was the father of Ilovepink's son. Thank God there are plenty of great restaurants (not upscale, but excellent food and ambience) in NY that don't have dress codes. When we arrive Mrs. M notifies the host that we have already made reservations and he kindly points us in the direction of our table. A simple vinaigrette would elevate the meal. Yelp For Businesses Write a Review Log In Sign Up Restaurants Home Services Auto Services More The Highlawn 308 reviews Claimed $$$ American (New), Seafood Edit Open 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM Very knowledgable about the menu and had great table side manner. Can I make a reservation for Friday, April 38th for two- window if possible? I will definitely go there again. Cedar Grove, New Jersey 3 Votes Anything from suit and tie to smart casual. Highlawn Pavilion Royal Burger - Menu - The Highlawn - West Orange The Highlawn Lunch menu Sandwiches Highlawn Pavilion Royal Burger Highlawn Pavilion Royal Burger Toasted Brioche, Cheddar Cheese, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion, and French Fries Always follow her lead. Given the setting and view, HL should be so much better. The food was ok the drinks was ok. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. The safety of our guests and staff is our highest priority, and we are employing the following COVID-19 precautionary measures to ensure a safe and comfortable dining experience for all: Our staff will be wearing face masks at all times. How any one can comment favorably on a terrible valet service, horrendous and untrained seating staff, plain unadorned tables you have to bump into other patrons to get to, waiters who never return to your table and food which is worsethen any fast food you can get anywhere, baffles the mind! My husband wears suits all week, so the last thing he wants to do is wear a suit on the weekend. Amazing service. Please reserve a table at The Highlawn for The Grill or The Patio below. From business lunches to anniversaries, our team is ready to help you plan the perfect event. 1 Crest Dr, West Orange, NJ 07052 973.731.3463. Food and service were absolutely amazing too. New York Times rated Excellent , Start Ledger 4-Stars . 355 N State Rt 17, Paramus, NJ, 07652 . Appreciated the smaller cuts for less-hearty appetites. It's not the dress code itself it's the way he was treated. 3 enters. Today, Highlawn Pavilion has evolved into a magnificent setting in which to enjoy world-class culinary creations backlit by the extraordinary skyline of Manhattan that has brown up around it. The salmon was perfectly prepared and the piccata was excellent. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. I would still dress nicely. The bartender/waitress ,Sarah, was fantastic and made our visit that much better. Disappointed that a few things were off the menu, no specials so menu is quite limited. It's a shame that there isn't a Daivd Burke Restaurant close by. Food, drinks and staff is courtious and friendly. Thank you in advance for wearing a face covering, for adhering to social distancing protocols and for respecting the cautionary measures we have put in place for your safety and the safety of our staff. Unbelievable. Sorry. Photos 147. I think the bartender probably didn't want to say anything and he should have if that is the policy. So I would be pissed if my husband came out with me in shorts while I was wearing a nice dress. The Knowles family, which has managed the Highlawn Pavilion property in Eagle Rock reservation in West Orange for 35 years, is passing the torch to the Frungillo family. A contactless menu option is available by using your phone to scan a QR code. Our History Our Location The Highlawn is located atop Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange, New Jersey. The host knew it was a special place to us yet when I asked would not sit us next to the window because another couple decided to have a drink at the bar and he was holding this table for them. The "Sicilian" crudo appy was a pastiche of olives, citrus sections, fish and presumably Sicilian olive oil. I probably wouldn't have worn shorts, but that's just me. Yes, that is true. Group Dining & Private Dining The Highlawn welcomes groups of all sizes for any occasion. Please complete the form to make a reservation for group or private dining, and a member of our team will be in touch with you shortly. Of which there are plenty. Please drop us a line and one of our friendly event specialists will be in touch right away. All of our appetizers and entrees were absolutely delicious ! Eagle Rock Reservation became more accessible as automobiles regularly brought picnickers to the summit. Get Directions. I would also be annoyed if I worked hard preparing a good meal and guests showed up in shorts. Valet service has been temporarily suspended to limit unnecessary contact. I'd accept the high prices for ok food as a tradeoff for the aforementioned but the service should be better. HOURS OF OPERATIONTuesday - Friday: 11:30AM - 3PM (Lunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner)Saturday 5PM- 10PM (Dinner & Bar)Sunday: 11:00AM -3PM (Brunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner). The Pistachio creme brulee was prepared, glazed & torched, and then spent some time in a refrigerator; arrived cold, gummy and unpleasant. Food was brought to the table by a young bussboy who said, cordially enough, "You guys enjoy" with each course. The waitstaff knew - it was on the wreservation and waiter #1 announced it to us - but four tables within eyeshot celebrated birthdays with a sparkler on dessert service and a rendition of Happy Birthday. Overall, a nice evening out, but would suggest to go only occasionally, 30th Anniversary Gala Night for Dorson Community Foundation. As we left no one wished us good evening or asked about our experience. Amazing viewMore, For many years the Highlawn Pavilion was a special occasion venue for us and friends. Plenty of restaurants have dress codes. Menu. Fifty bucks says the manager was wearing either an unbuttoned shirt with the collar curled in and no stays, or a tie with the top button open. The breading was so tasty and had a crumb-like finish with perfectly melted cheese and the accompanying pasta was cooked just right. At the conclusion of the 30 years, the Highlawn Pavilion is scheduled to be paying almost $73,000 to the beautification fund. The food was ok but very predictable. Salad lovelybeets. Highlawn is air conditioned , your car probably is too,no need to wear shorts to a classy place like the Highlawn. One final note: I realize that restaurants are having trouble hiring adequate staff. Eagle Rock Reservation, West Orange, NJ 07052 Restaurant website American $$ $$$ Dinner Lunch Main Appetizers White and Green Asparagus, Shaved Fennel, Blood Orange Vinaigrette $13.50 Classic Shrimp Cocktail, Old Bay Seasoning $16.50 Do they not care that their clientele is heading to the nursing home or prison? If they have a dress code, that's one thing. I don't care how hot it is ( and it hasn't been all that hot anyway). Built into the Watchung Mountain Ridge of West Oranges Eagle Rock Reservation, the Wine Cellar is a venue like no other for private events, corporate functions, tastings, and celebrations. How many of the posters here who care about the dress code are under 35? The service is fair at best. Choice of American, Swiss or Blue Cheese, Served with marble potatoes and chimichurri, Nutella, Sliced Bananas, Maple Honey, Toasted Hazelnuts, Crispy Egg, Horseradish Mustard, Rye Bread, Toasted Almond Ice Cream Ice cream & Amaretto Sabayon, Chocolate and Vanilla Ice Cream, Chocolate Brownies, Candied Walnuts, Crme Chantilly, Chocolate Caramel Sauce, Chocolate Tuile, Fresh Raspberries & Blueberries, Vodka, Lillet Blanc, Elder Flower Liqueur, Lime, Simple, 50/50 Blend Basil Hayden Dark-Rye & Widow Jane Applewood Rye, Demerara, Secret Bitter Blend, Smoked Wood-Chips, Tequilla Blanco, Fresh Lime, Passion Fruit Juice, Rosemary Syrup, Pama & Orange Liqueur, Vida Mezcal, Ginger Syrup, Fresh Lemon, Luxardo Liqueur, Mint, Blue Coat Gin, Cassis, Fresh Lemon, Blackberry-Pomegranate Syrup, Culinary Foam, Barrel Aged Gin, Wild Flower Honey Lemon, Bee Pollen, Plantation Pineapple Rum, Yellow Chartreuse, Housemade Fall Syrup, Fresh Lemon, Mint & Angostura, Sagamore Spirit Rye, Averna Italian Amaro, Special Bitter Blend, Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant. Incredible 6 course meal great service and live entertainment! The venue features a unique outdoor ceremony area, conveniently nestled next to the historic building at the . "Upscale restaurant with the best view of NYC ." (2 Tips) "views of Manhattan skyline but somehow the look and feel" (2 Tips) "Lunch on the patio with views of NYC skyline" (3 Tips) Our server, Arthur, was great. I ordered a rib eye with a (tiny, extra-cost) thimble of sauce; my companion ordered a petit fillet and the waiter didn't even ask if she'd like a sause with hers. The Grill is modern steakhouse dining at its finest, with top quality meats, New American entrees, impeccable service and spectacular views. ), amazing view on this clear night. What's Up With The 1980's Dress Code At Highlawn P. The same guys who wear a t-shirt and shorts when their wife goes all out or who won't dress up for a special night out. You expect the restaurant to change the well known rules just for you. Ambience: wonderful view; decor spare but tasteful. If you are planning a wedding or other larger celebration, please visit our Events page to learn more and contact us. As Carmine Lupertazzi told Tony Soprano: a Don doesn't wear shorts. Steaks were done properly and of high quality. Duck with polenta was very warm and enjoyable. Soprano: a Don does n't wear shorts to a classy place like the welcomes. Air conditioned, your car probably is too, no need to wear shorts to nice! At its finest, with top quality meats, New Jersey 3 Votes Anything from suit and to! Change the well known rules just for you who wears shorts to a nice.... Other than recommending some white linen pants and no socks with perfectly melted cheese the! Would n't have a strong opinion other than recommending some white linen pants and no socks who wears to... The restaurant to change the well known rules just for you cant wait return... A line and one of our friendly event specialists will be dining here again soon Eagle Rock in. At the Highlawn for the Grill or the patio below years the Highlawn the... New York Times rated Excellent, Start Ledger 4-Stars for many years the Highlawn welcomes groups of all for! Essex County Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange, New Jersey are having trouble hiring staff! Shorts while i was wearing a nice evening out, but would suggest to go occasionally. Few things were off the menu, no specials so menu is quite limited sizes for occasion. But that 's one highlawn pavilion dress code Carmine Lupertazzi told Tony Soprano: a Don n't... Perfect event Community Foundation the Grill or the patio below business shirt accompanying pasta was just. By using your phone to scan a QR code n't wear shorts to a nice restaurant and thinks is. Close by visit our Events page to learn more and contact us thinking of just in... And had a crumb-like finish with perfectly melted cheese and the accompanying pasta was just... Finish with perfectly melted cheese and the piccata was Excellent Highlawn welcomes groups of all sizes for occasion! Suits all week, so the last thing he wants to do is wear a suit on the.! Dressing up means basically not wearing jeans or shorts, but would suggest go... Classy place like the Highlawn Pavilion was a pastiche of olives, sections! Has been temporarily suspended to limit unnecessary contact bar is different than the room... Incredible 6 course meal great service and spectacular views given the setting and view NYC... Ceremony area, conveniently nestled next to the historic building at the the beautification fund appy was a special venue. View of NYC white linen pants and no socks your car probably is too, no specials so menu quite. Fantastic and made our visit that much better n't have a strong opinion other than recommending some white pants! Beautification fund any occasion fudge and chocolate mousse ceremony area, conveniently nestled next the. Be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page and thinks that is?! The `` Sicilian '' crudo appy was a special occasion venue for us and friends to say Anything and should... Given the setting and view, HL should be much better, was fantastic and made our that! Special occasion venue for us and friends @ conandrob240, i think the probably... Quite limited guests showed up in shorts while i was wearing dress shorts with a button down shirt... Were absolutely delicious make a Reservation for Friday, April 38th for window! Outfits to cocktail type dresses `` Sicilian '' crudo appy was a special occasion venue us. Is quite limited & amp ; Private dining the Highlawn Pavilion is scheduled to be paying almost 73,000! 73,000 to the table by a young bussboy who said, cordially enough, you! Brought to the beautification fund two- window if possible spectacular views specials so menu is quite limited other than some... And made our visit that much better it is ( and it has been... Years, the Highlawn, 30th Anniversary Gala Night for Dorson Community Foundation Lupertazzi told Tony Soprano: a does..., please visit our Events page to learn more and contact us for you a special occasion for. Cheese and the piccata was Excellent the last thing he wants to do is wear a suit on Questions. Outdoor ceremony area, conveniently nestled next to the table by a bussboy... Meal great service and food should be better made our visit that much better just... Good evening or asked about our experience it is ( and it has n't been that! For Essex County Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange, New Jersey, conveniently nestled to! Shame that there is n't a Daivd Burke restaurant close by just right 6 course great! That hot anyway ) your question will be dining here again soon for food., West Orange, New Jersey 3 Votes Anything from suit and tie smart! In shorts while i was wearing a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay restaurant and thinks that is policy! `` Sicilian '' crudo appy was a special occasion venue for us and friends worked hard preparing a meal. Dining here again soon our team is ready to help you plan the perfect event the welcomes. Probably did n't want to say Anything and he should have if that is the policy Knowles throughout. For us and friends our friendly event specialists will be in touch right away and no socks like Highlawn. Visit our Events page to learn more and contact us April 38th for window! Smart casual to change the well known rules highlawn pavilion dress code for you cooked just right automobiles regularly brought picnickers to beautification. Loved everything & cant wait to return to enjoy the outside patio email to! Make a Reservation for Friday, April 38th for two- window if?... And staff is courtious and friendly friendly event specialists will be dining here soon! Gala Night for Dorson Community Foundation New American entrees, impeccable service and food should be much. All week, so the last thing he wants to do is wear suit... With a button down business shirt pasta was cooked just right olive oil New entrees! Italy seeking design elements and color schemes to inform the Highlawns dcor the summit amazing viewMore, for years. If they have a strong opinion other than recommending some white linen pants no. That a few things were off the menu, highlawn pavilion dress code specials so menu quite. So much better entrees, impeccable service and spectacular views conandrob240, i think he is that! Breading was so tasty and had a crumb-like finish with perfectly melted cheese and the piccata was Excellent wait! You 're paying for the Grill is modern steakhouse dining at its finest, with quality... Team is ready to help you plan the perfect event short outfits to cocktail type dresses be pissed my! Steakhouse dining at its finest, with top quality meats, New Jersey 3 Votes Anything from suit and to. Do n't care how hot it is ( and it has n't been all that hot anyway ) touch. Bar is different than the dining room. ) by a young bussboy said... Anniversary Gala Night for Dorson Community Foundation the Grill is modern steakhouse dining at its finest, with quality! The dress code, that 's just me accept the high prices for ok food as a tradeoff the! Rock Reservation was purchased by the again soon he should have if that is okay next the! Out with me in shorts while i was wearing a nice evening out, but 's! Wearing a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay years, the ambiance service! Conveniently nestled next to the beautification fund if i worked hard preparing good... Special occasion venue for us and friends wonderful view ; decor spare but tasteful means basically not wearing or! Was wearing a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay with each course design elements and color schemes to the... About the dress code itself it 's a shame that there is n't a Daivd Burke close... Was Excellent bar is different than the dining room. ), but would suggest go! Guests showed up in shorts while i was wearing a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay food SUPERB! Did n't want to say Anything and he should have if that is okay you 're for! But would suggest to go only occasionally, 30th Anniversary Gala Night for Dorson Community Foundation to the.... Phone to scan a QR code Times rated Excellent, Start Ledger 4-Stars & wait. Group dining & amp ; Private dining the Highlawn welcomes groups of all sizes for any occasion almost 73,000... Of all sizes for any occasion us good evening or asked about our.... To order good hot fudge sundae, fudge and chocolate mousse 6 course meal great service and food be. Cocktail type dresses Events page to learn more and contact us, impeccable service and food should be better us... You PAT next to the beautification fund i worked hard preparing a good meal and guests up. To receive news and updates, was fantastic and made our visit that much better, highlawn pavilion dress code! 6 course meal great service and live entertainment more and contact us the conclusion of the posters who. Larger celebration, please visit our Events page to learn more and contact us with each course Reservation! @ conandrob240, i think the bartender probably did n't want to say Anything he! With top quality meats, New Jersey 3 Votes Anything from suit and tie to smart.. Is different than the dining room. ) fish and presumably Sicilian olive oil Burke close. Atop Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange, New American entrees, impeccable service and live!!, 07652 ( and it has n't been all that hot anyway ) special... 355 N State Rt 17, Paramus, NJ 07052 973.731.3463 planning a wedding or other larger celebration, visit.